How Schemas Affect Us In A Negative Way

Before we can really dive into this topic, it’s best to clarify what a schema is. Schemas are automatically created cognitive frameworks that help guide the way we think about and understand the world around us (Duff, Peace, Think Social Psychology) In simpler terms, schemas are the preconceived ideas we have about how a certain situation or action should go. Picture going to a water park, first you’re going to pay to get in, next you make your way to the change room where you put on your swim suit, then you proceed out to the pool for a couple hours of swimming and enjoying the water attractions. Regardless if you’ve been to this specific water park or not, you’re able to go through the process of getting to the pool with ease, because you already have a schema in your mind. So in this sense, schemas are good, and there’s no denying that schemas can be good in many ways, but can they also effect us negatively? Unfortunately yes.

While cognitive organization can come in handy for a lot of situations, it can also affect one is quite the pessimistic way. Say for instance that you have a negative experience at the dentist the last time you went. Regardless of how many times you’ve been without an incident, this unfavourable memory will stick inside your brain, and alter the pre-existing schema you had before. Now, every time you have to go to the dentist, you will recall on the negative experience and be hesitant, or in some cases, fearful to go. In this sense, schemas can lead to the development of certain fears. “Negative events may edge out positive ones in our memories, according to research by Kensinger and others” (Andrea Thompson, 2007) Furthermore, individuals can also develop a depressive self schema, meaning that one experiences “a well-organized and interconnected negative internal representation of self” (David J.A. Dozois, Lena C. Quilty) This schema can develop from failures throughout life, poor relationships, bullying and overall low self esteem. Unfortunately, the depressive self schema plays a large part in many individuals struggle with depression.

It is also very possible to develop certain schemas like the subjugation schema, which can quickly demonstrate control over one’s life. With the subjugation schema, individuals will allow others to dominate or take advantage of them, stemming from the fear that the people in their lives will desert them, or in some cases, punish them. This schema is causes from previous toxic relationships and experiences with people. An individual remembers the negative consequences they suffered at the hands of someone else during a confrontation, and fears repeating them. This can also develop from emotional abuse, as a large part of this schema revolves around “the perception that one’s own needs and feelings are not valid and important to other people” (Young, 2002)

Those these are only a few examples, it becomes clear that schemas are not always helpful, and can indeed have negative impacts. Though it is true that these schemas have developed from terrible past experiences, relationships or situations, it is the schemas or memories themselves that can keep people trapped in their harmful ways and thoughts. Situations become memories, and those memories form your schemas, leading to how you perceive others and the world around you. With that in mind, we should all be careful what kind of schemas we are leaving people with when it comes to ourselves and the situations that we share.

References

Young, 2002 http://healingschemas.tumblr.com/post/91585127370/12-subjugation-schema

David J. A. Dozois, PhD, Lena C. Quilty http://www.apa.org/science/about/psa/2013/06/depressive-self-schema.aspx

Andrea Thompson, 2007 http://www.livescience.com/1827-bad-memories-stick-good.html

Kimberly Duff, Kristine 2013 Peace, Think social Psychology: Canadian Edition

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “How Schemas Affect Us In A Negative Way

  1. Personally I believe that schemas can be both a good and a bad thing for people, depending on what they are based on. For example, if a child begins to perceive the world generally as hostile, then most interactions the child will have will be negative. If they generalize certain situations or other’s behavior as being hostile, then their own reactions to most of their environment are aggressive. This begins a vicious cycle that can continue into adulthood if not addressed at a young age. So because they have this general hostile idea about the world they stop interpreting the world around them and just assume everything is hostile. But a child who does not carry these hostile schemas in their mind would stop and interpret different situations, or recognize that the these situations are not hostile at all.

    Huesmann, L. R. (1998). The role of social information processing and cognitive schema in the acquisition and maintenance of habitual aggressive behavior.

    Like

  2. I agree that schemas can be both good and bad all depending on the type of schemas. But I also think that even negative schemas have some positive principles. These are that schemas can be identified in people and in turn can be worked on to hopefully change the view of their schema through positive reinforcement networks. This lays down a pathway for standardized pathways and guidelines for helping persons with negative schemas. Although I understand if these just didn’t have to exist in general that would be best, I am happy that we are able to identify negative schema and because of that have a pathway for success to hopefully provide these persons with the support they need.

    Padesky, C. A. (n.d.). Schema Change Processes in Cognitive Therapy. Retrieved January 30, 2017, from http://www.psycholoogjanslegers.nl/attachments/article/10/007_schema_change_article_permissions.pdf

    Like

  3. Thanks for posting, I remember first learning about schemas in a social psychology class and found it to be interesting. I read an article about schemas that are formed in early childhood and depending on whether they are good or bad can affect that child into adolescence. In a retrospective study conducted on adolescence, it was found that schema themes such as self-worthlessness that were formed in early childhood resulted in depression in their teen years. I found that to be so sad, I hope more parents can realize that their child’s self worth is important. Anyways here’s the link if you’d like to take a read! http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10608-006-9100-3

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s